OUR STORY

Welcome to Carlo's Homemade Sauce, where flavor meets tradition!

Born in Sicily, Italy, Carlo developed a love for cooking at a young age. His passion for cooking is what led him to come to America in the hopes of fulfilling his dream of owning a restaurant. As an immigrant driven by ambition, he founded Carlo's Pizzeria in Middle Village, New York. Established in 1966, the iconic pizzeria still remains at the same location for the last 60 years.

Three generations later, we proudly continue to honor Carlo’s legacy and family values. Our mission remains to share the love and tradition of his cherished and most celebrated recipes.

From our family to yours, every great meal starts with Carlo's homemade!

EVERY GREAT MEAL STARTS WITH CARLO’S HOMEMADE

FEATURED PRODUCT

Carlo’s Homemade of NY Tomato Sauce – Pack of 3 (32oz) Jars

$38.99

Carlo's Homemade of NY tomato sauce has a rich history dating back to 1966 when it was first introduced at Carlo's Pizzeria and Restaurant in Middle Village. And now, we are thrilled to announce that you can finally savor our sauce at home. Our sauce will bring the taste of our restaurant right to your kitchen!

All-Natural, Non GMO, Gluten Free, and Vegan. No added sugars or preservatives. Made with only the finest ingredients - San Marzano tomatoes, Onions, Italian Olive Oil, Sea Salt, Cracked Black Pepper, and Oregano.

You can use our sauce to make pasta, pizza, meatballs, any parmigiana, a base to any dish, the list can go on there are so many options!

GALLERY

TESTIMONIALS

Ever since I discovered Carlo's Homemade Sauce, my spaghetti and meatballs have been a hit at family dinners. It’s like bringing a piece of Italy into our home. Pure, flavorful, and simply the best!

Emily

New York, NY

I was skeptical at first, but Carlo's Sauce has no comparison. The mozzarella sticks dip recipe on their website is to die for. It’s a staple at our game nights now.

Derek

Miami, FL

The secret to my mouthwatering pizza? Carlo's Sauce! Spread over homemade dough with just the right toppings – it's pizza perfection. This sauce truly elevates every meal.

Michael

Chicago, IL

A jar of Carlo's Homemade Sauce is a jar of pure love. My chicken parmesan has never tasted better. It's our little secret to a perfect dinner.

Rachel

Austin, TX

Carlo's Tomato Sauce is a game-changer for my vegan meals. I use it in my pasta primavera, and it's an explosion of flavor. Fresh, vibrant, and so versatile!

Samantha

San Francisco, CA

Cooking with Carlo's Sauce brings back memories of my grandfather’s kitchen. The sausage and pepper skillet is a weeknight favorite. Authentic taste, every time.

Josh

Austin, TX

Flavor is phenomenal and can be used in so many ways. Especially when you’re in a hurry. Won’t be the last time you hear about Carlos Homemade of NY!

Chris

Carlos sauce is always the best to pick. I've tried many brands but in all honesty no one beats Carlos . It is truly the best.

Wolf

Carlos Homemade is the most amazing jarred sauce for a perfect at home meal 🤩😋🍝

Stacey - Wannabe Foodie

I actually made penne alla vodka with Carlo’s Homemade sauce and it was fantastic

Jenny

By far the best sauce I ever bought. So delicious 😋 definitely worth it. Quality like I cooked it all day.❤️

silly_b_19

Carlos Homemade Jarred all natural tomato sauce was so delicious and so easy to make🙌

Carlo's Homemade